When Janie's younger brother Paul comes to visit, Shelly discovers that his longtime crush on her still exists, and she isn't quite sure how to handle it now that he's all grown up.
Still fond of Grant, the man she almost married, Shelly takes him to lunch in an effort to remain friends. But this becomes a monumental task after he informs her that he's newly engaged and introduces her to his new love.
After J.T. fails an anatomy test, his mother, Frances, embarrasses him by begging cranky Professor Dunson to let J.T. take a makeup test.
Nick falls in love with his girlfriend and wants to fully commit to her, she reveals that she's still married. Meanwhile, Shelly discovers that Rita is always around her loft since Rita's convinced her place is haunted.
When four high school best friends' lives are dramatically changed on the night of a near fatal accident, eighteen years later they're reunited, only to discover that a set of past and present secrets will alter their course.
A conservative writer who's sworn off dating is swept off her feet by a man who, she learns, works for an upscale dating service.