L.A. Reid Says He Thought Teairra Mari Would've Been A Bigger Star Than Rihanna

Entertainment | 01/08/2016 | 12:30 PM EST

Successful music exec had his money on the 'Make Her Feel Good' singer

L.A. Reid has a proven track record of separating the stars from the wannabes (i.e. Toni Braxton, Usher, TLC, Outkast, etc.), but every hunch doesn't exactly pan out.

In his new memoir "Sing to Me: My Story of Making Music, Finding Magic, and Searching for Who's Next.," the Epic Records CEO reveals a time when he thought Teairra Mari would've been a bigger star than the powerhouse that is Rihanna. In an excerpt from the book (via Billboard), Reid wrote:

"At Island Def Jam, Jay Z, whom I'd hired to be president of Def Jam, became one of my great teachers. When he first brought Rihanna into the office for an audition in February 2005, we worked like a team.

I first laid eyes on her in the hallway. I didn't know she was a singer or anything, just a pretty girl standing outside somebody's office. Then Jay Z burst into my office.

'You have to see this girl,' he said.We went back to his office and he introduced me. She was a startlingly beautiful 17-year-old from Barbados. She opened her audition with a Beyoncé song, singing, but the whole time piercing me with these laser eyes. I saw her determination, her commitment. I saw someone who was going to be a big star someday. My head was spinning. She sang another song, 'Pon De Replay,' that would become her first hit. After she was done, I looked at Jay Z.

'Don't let her leave the building,' I said.

I left it to Jay Z's guys to close the deal, and she signed her contract that day.

After signing Rihanna, Jay Z and his team did the A&R for her first album, and I had nothing to do with it. The funny thing about Rihanna's success was that we signed two girls at that time -- Rihanna and a lovely young lady named Teairra Mari. We had an in-house company showcase and Beyoncé happened to be there with Jay Z. Teairra Mari, Rihanna, a four-girl group called Black Butterfly and Ne-Yo performed. At the label, we thought Teairra Mari would be the big star. We spent more time on her, did more work on her, paid more attention to her. Rihanna already had a hit with 'Pon De Replay,' but we still thought it was the other girl. A bell went off for me, however, when, after the showcase, Beyoncé came up to me.

'That Rihanna girl,' she said, 'she's a beast.'"

As we now know, Rihanna has gone on to release seven albums, achieve 13 No. 1 singles, win eight Grammy Awards, receive a Fashion Icon lifetime achievement award from the Council of Fashion Designers of America and much more. Teairra's career highlights include her debut album (featuring the hit single "Make Her Feel Good") and a spot on VH1's "Love & Hip Hop Hollywood."

(Photos from left: Jesse Grant/Getty Images for VH1, Frazer Harrison/Getty Images, Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images)

related stories

Top 100 of 2016

Centric's counting down the best music videos of the year!

Get Real

Tamar Braxton Laughs At The Real's Ratings Struggle

The Blind Side

Kim Kardashian Blind-Sided By Kanye's Nervous Breakdown